A search for someone’s name can reveal information published years ago: old news reports, outdated personal details, embarrassing photographs, court records or content that no longer reflects the person’s life. Even when information is accurate, its continued visibility can affect employment opportunities, relationships and personal reputation.
The right to be forgotten was developed to address some of these problems. Under the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), individuals can request the deletion of personal data in certain circumstances. They may also ask search engines to remove links to specific results when the legal requirements are met.
However, this right is not an unlimited power to erase the past. It must be balanced against freedom of expression, public interest, journalism, historical records and other legal obligations. Understanding how it worksâand where it falls shortâis essential for individuals, companies, publishers and technology platforms.
1. What Is the Right to Be Forgotten?
The right to be forgotten is commonly used to describe a person’s ability to request the removal of personal information from certain systems or search results when legal conditions are satisfied.
In the EU, the legal foundation is primarily Article 17 of the GDPR, which formally establishes the right to erasure. It allows individuals to ask organizations responsible for processing their personal data to delete it in specified circumstances.
The concept is particularly relevant to the internet because personal information can remain accessible long after its original purpose has ended. Search engines make this problem more visible by connecting old information to a person’s name.
Examples of information someone may want removed
- Outdated personal contact details published online.
- Old photographs or personal information shared without a valid legal basis.
- Information that is inaccurate or no longer relevant in the circumstances.
- Personal data collected or processed unlawfully.
- Old account information held by a company that no longer needs it.
- Search results linking a person’s name to information that meets the legal criteria for delisting.
Erasure versus delisting: two different actions
| Action | What happens? | What remains possible? |
|---|---|---|
| Erasure by a website | The controller deletes personal data from the relevant system where the request is legally justified. | Copies, backups or information held by other organizations may still exist, subject to applicable rules. |
| Search engine delisting | A search engine removes particular URLs from results for searches associated with a person’s name in the relevant scope. | The original page may remain online and can potentially be found through other search terms or websites. |
| Correction | Inaccurate personal information is corrected. | The corrected information may remain published. |
| Restriction of processing | An organization limits how it uses personal data in certain circumstances. | The data may still be stored while the restriction applies. |
2. Where Did the Right to Be Forgotten Originate?
The modern European understanding of the right to be forgotten is closely connected to a landmark 2014 case involving Google Spain and a Spanish citizen, Mario Costeja GonzĂĄlez.
Google Spain v AEPD and Mario Costeja GonzĂĄlez (2014)
The dispute concerned newspaper announcements published in 1998 relating to a property auction connected with social security debts. Years later, the information still appeared prominently when people searched for Costeja’s name on Google.
He asked the Spanish data protection authority to require Google and the newspaper to remove or conceal the information. The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) ruled that search engine operators could be responsible for processing personal data when they index and display search results.
The Court concluded that individuals could, in certain circumstances, request the removal of links to information that was inadequate, irrelevant or no longer relevant, or excessive in relation to the purposes of the processing. The decision also emphasized the need to balance privacy rights against the public’s interest in accessing information.
Why it matters: The judgment established that search engines have independent data protection responsibilities. A person may have a valid request against a search engine even when the original webpage remains lawful and online.From the 2014 judgment to GDPR Article 17
The GDPR became applicable on May 25, 2018, and expressly included the right to erasure in Article 17. The regulation provides several grounds for requesting deletion and identifies circumstances in which organizations may refuse.
The right is therefore broader than the original search engine dispute. It applies to personal data processed by organizations, not just information displayed in search results.
3. How GDPR Article 17 Works
Article 17 gives individuals the right to obtain erasure of personal data concerning them without undue delay when at least one of the specified legal grounds applies.
The six grounds for requesting erasure
An organization collected personal information for a particular purpose but no longer needs it. For example, a business may no longer need certain customer information after the relevant service relationship has ended, subject to legal retention requirements.
If an organization relies on consent to process personal data, an individual may withdraw that consent. Erasure may be required if no other legal basis supports continued processing.
A person may object to processing based on legitimate interests or public task grounds. If there are no overriding legitimate grounds for continuing, erasure may be required. An objection to direct marketing must be respected for that marketing activity.
If personal information was collected or used in violation of applicable data protection law, the individual may request deletion.
An organization may be legally required to delete personal data under applicable EU or member state law.
Article 17 covers personal data collected in relation to the offer of information society services referred to in Article 8(1), where the relevant consent requirements apply. This is particularly relevant to information collected from children using online services.
What happens after a valid request?
Where a controller is required to erase personal data, it must do so without undue delay. If it has made the information public, Article 17(2) requires it to take reasonable steps to inform other controllers processing the data that the individual has requested deletion of links to, or copies or replications of, that information.
The controller must consider available technology and the cost of implementation when deciding what steps are reasonable. Article 19 also addresses communication of erasure to recipients to whom the personal data has been disclosed, subject to the stated exceptions.
Organizations generally have one month to respond to a request under Article 12(3). This period can be extended by up to two additional months where necessary because of the complexity or number of requests, provided the individual is informed of the extension and the reasons within the initial month.
4. How to Remove Information from Search Results
Search engines such as Google process personal data when they index webpages and display links in response to searches. Under European data protection law, individuals can request delisting of certain results when the relevant legal conditions are met.
However, search engine delisting is not automatic. The company evaluates the request, the nature of the information, its accuracy, how long ago it was published, the person’s role in public life and the public interest in continued access.
What can make a search result eligible for delisting?
- The information is inaccurate or materially misleading.
- The information is outdated and no longer relevant to the original purpose.
- The content is excessive or inadequate in relation to the circumstances.
- The information concerns a private individual rather than someone with a significant public role.
- The public interest in accessing the information is limited compared with the individual’s privacy interests.
- The processing of the personal data does not have a sufficient legal basis.
How to request removal from Google
- Identify the exact URLs appearing in search results for your name.
- Record the search terms that produce the results.
- Explain why the information is inaccurate, outdated, irrelevant or otherwise meets the applicable legal criteria.
- Provide relevant context, such as the date of publication, whether the information has been corrected and why continued visibility is disproportionate.
- Submit the request through Google’s legal removal process for privacy-related requests.
- Keep a copy of the submission and any correspondence.
Google may ask for identity verification and additional information. A successful delisting generally affects searches related to the person’s name within the relevant geographic scope. It does not necessarily remove the page from Google’s index for every possible search.
Google’s own explanation of its process is available through its Right to Be Forgotten overview.
5. How to Submit a Right-to-Erasure Request
A well-prepared request should identify the personal data, explain the legal reason for deletion and give the organization enough information to locate the relevant records.
Step-by-step process
Determine which company, website, public authority or other organization controls the processing of your personal data. If several organizations hold copies, separate requests may be necessary.
Identify the account, webpage, database record, email address, photograph, profile or other personal information involved. Include URLs or account references where appropriate.
State which Article 17 ground applies. For example, explain that the data is no longer necessary, that consent has been withdrawn without another lawful basis, or that the information was processed unlawfully.
The organization may need to verify your identity before disclosing or deleting personal information. Provide only the information reasonably necessary for verification, and use a secure submission channel.
Use the organization’s privacy contact, data protection officer or official rights-request form. Keep a record of the date and the information submitted.
The organization should respond within the applicable time limit. If it refuses, it should explain the reasons and inform you about your right to complain to a supervisory authority and seek a judicial remedy.
Example request template
Subject: Request for Erasure of Personal Data Under GDPR Article 17
Dear Data Protection Officer,
I am writing to request the erasure of personal data concerning me that your organization processes.
The information concerned is: [describe the data, account, webpage or record].
I believe that erasure is required under Article 17 of the GDPR because [explain the relevant legal ground, such as the data is no longer necessary, consent has been withdrawn and no other legal basis applies, or the processing is unlawful].
Please review this request and confirm whether the personal data will be erased. If you have disclosed the information to other recipients, please also consider your obligations under Articles 17(2) and 19 of the GDPR.
If you decide not to comply, please explain the legal reasons for your decision and provide information about the available complaint and appeal procedures.
Kind regards,
[Full name]
[Contact details]
This is a general template. The request should be adapted to the actual circumstances and the applicable law.
6. Where the Right to Be Forgotten Falls Short
Despite its importance, the right to be forgotten has significant limitations. The internet is decentralized, information can be copied quickly and different countries apply different legal standards. A successful request may reduce the visibility of information without eliminating every copy.
1. Freedom of expression and information
One of the most important exceptions concerns freedom of expression and information. Article 17(3)(a) allows personal data to remain available when processing is necessary for exercising these rights.
This exception is particularly relevant to journalism, public-interest reporting, academic publications and other forms of legitimate expression. A person cannot automatically force a newspaper to remove a lawful report simply because it is embarrassing or damaging to their reputation.
2. Public interest and historical records
Information may remain available when it is necessary for a task carried out in the public interest or for exercising official authority. Public records, historical archives and certain government databases may therefore be protected by legal exceptions.
For example, a request to remove a historical report about a public official may be weighed differently from a request concerning outdated personal information about someone with no public role.
3. Legal obligations and recordkeeping
Organizations may be required to retain certain records under tax, accounting, employment, financial or other laws. Even if a customer closes an account or withdraws consent for a particular activity, the organization may have a separate legal reason to retain limited information.
4. Information may remain on the original website
Search engine delisting does not necessarily require a publisher to remove the source material. A webpage may remain accessible through its direct URL, internal site search, links from other websites or searches using terms other than the person’s name.
5. Copies and reposts can survive
Content may be duplicated across social media, forums, archives, screenshots, news aggregators and other websites. A successful request to one organization does not automatically remove every copy held by independent controllers.
6. Search engines make individual assessments
There is no guarantee that a search engine will approve a request. It may consider the information accurate, relevant to public debate or important for users to access. The outcome can depend on the individual’s role, the nature of the content and the circumstances of publication.
7. Geographic limits
The territorial reach of delisting is another major limitation. In 2019, the CJEU ruled in Google LLC v CNIL that EU data protection law did not require search engines to delist results globally across all versions of their services.
Search engines may apply delisting to EU or relevant regional search versions and use location signals to limit access in certain circumstances. But the same information may remain accessible to users in other parts of the world.
8. Different countries have different rules
The GDPR applies within its territorial scope, but it does not create a universal worldwide right to erase all online information. Other jurisdictions may have different privacy laws, remedies and exceptions. A request that succeeds under EU law may not produce the same result elsewhere.
9. Identity verification can create additional friction
Organizations may need to confirm that the person making a request is the individual concerned or an authorized representative. This can involve additional documentation and delay, especially when multiple organizations hold the information.
10. It cannot guarantee complete anonymity
Even when personal information is deleted from one service, other organizations may hold lawful copies. Public records, archived materials and previously downloaded information can remain available under applicable legal exceptions.
7. Important Legal Cases That Define the Limits
Google Spain v AEPD (2014)
The CJEU recognized that search engines may have to remove links to personal information that is inadequate, irrelevant or no longer relevant, or excessive in relation to the purposes of processing. The ruling also required a balance between individual privacy rights and the public interest in accessing information.
Lesson: Search engines have their own data protection responsibilities, separate from those of the websites they index.
Google v CNIL (2019)
The CJEU considered whether a successful delisting request under EU data protection law had to apply worldwide. It held that EU law did not require global delisting across all versions of a search engine.
The Court nevertheless emphasized that search engines must take measures that effectively protect individuals’ rights within the EU. Depending on the circumstances, location-based restrictions may be relevant.
Lesson: The right to be forgotten has territorial boundaries. Removing a result in Europe does not necessarily remove it from search results elsewhere.
GC and Others v CNIL (2019)
In a separate 2019 judgment, the CJEU addressed delisting requests involving sensitive personal data, including information about criminal proceedings, political opinions and health-related matters.
The Court recognized that sensitive data requires particularly careful treatment. It also explained that search engines must assess whether continued access is strictly necessary to protect the public’s right to information, considering the circumstances of the individual case.
Lesson: Sensitive personal information may receive stronger protection, but the result still depends on the applicable legal balance.
EDPB Coordinated Enforcement Framework report (2026)
The European Data Protection Board published a report on coordinated enforcement activity concerning the right to erasure. It emphasizes that Article 17 is not absolute and that controllers must evaluate the legal grounds for deletion alongside the exceptions that can justify continued processing.
Lesson: The practical application of the right requires organizations to assess requests individually rather than automatically deleting or automatically refusing all personal data.
8. Right to Be Forgotten vs. Freedom of Expression
The right to privacy and the right to freedom of expression can conflict. A person may want an old article removed, while journalists, researchers or members of the public may argue that the information remains important.
European data protection law does not establish a simple rule that privacy always wins or that publication always wins. Instead, the relevant circumstances must be assessed.
| Factor | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Accuracy | False or materially misleading information may strengthen the case for correction or erasure. |
| Age of information | Older information may become less relevant, although age alone does not guarantee deletion. |
| Public role | Information about public officials or people with prominent public roles may carry greater public interest. |
| Nature of the information | Highly sensitive personal information can raise stronger privacy concerns. |
| Original purpose | Whether continued processing remains necessary and proportionate is important. |
| Public interest | Information relevant to public safety, accountability, historical research or public debate may remain accessible. |
| Impact on the individual | The consequences of continued publication may be relevant to the balancing exercise. |
This balancing exercise is central to the right’s limitations. The goal is not to rewrite history, but to ensure that personal data is processed in a way that respects privacy without unnecessarily restricting access to legitimate information.
9. What Companies, Publishers and Websites Need to Know
Organizations that collect, publish or index personal information should have a clear process for handling erasure requests. Ignoring a request or automatically rejecting it can create compliance risks.
For companies processing customer data
- Provide a clear privacy contact or rights-request channel.
- Identify personal data held across relevant systems and vendors.
- Verify identity proportionately before taking action.
- Assess each request against Article 17 and the applicable exceptions.
- Delete information where required, including relevant copies under the organization’s control.
- Notify recipients where required by Article 19.
- Keep a record of the request, assessment and outcome.
For news publishers and online media
- Assess whether the content serves a legitimate public information purpose.
- Distinguish requests for correction from requests for deletion.
- Consider whether updating an article could address outdated or misleading information.
- Evaluate privacy rights alongside freedom of expression and national media law.
- Document the reasoning behind decisions to retain or remove content.
For search engines and online platforms
- Provide accessible privacy-removal procedures.
- Assess each URL and the relevant search context.
- Consider the individual’s public role and the public interest.
- Apply appropriate geographic restrictions where legally required.
- Explain decisions and provide information about available complaint mechanisms.
10. What Can You Do If a Request Is Rejected?
A refusal does not necessarily mean the matter is over. If an organization rejects an erasure request, the individual can examine the explanation and consider the available remedies.
- Ask for clarification: Request the specific legal grounds for refusing deletion.
- Review the evidence: Check whether the organization understood the information and circumstances correctly.
- Consider another right: Correction, restriction of processing or objection may be more appropriate than erasure in some cases.
- Complain to a supervisory authority: Individuals can lodge a complaint with the relevant data protection authority where the GDPR applies.
- Consider judicial remedies: Depending on the circumstances and national law, court proceedings may be available.
- Contact the publisher separately: If the concern involves the original webpage, a direct request to the publisher may address issues that search engine delisting cannot solve.
Under GDPR Article 77, individuals generally have the right to lodge a complaint with a supervisory authority if they consider that processing of their personal data infringes the regulation. Article 79 also provides a right to an effective judicial remedy against controllers or processors in the circumstances set out by the regulation.
11. Practical Right-to-Be-Forgotten Checklist
Use this checklist to organize a potential request before contacting a website, company or search engine.
12. Frequently Asked Questions
What is the right to be forgotten?
It is the commonly used name for the right to erasure under GDPR Article 17. It allows individuals to request deletion of personal data when one of the specified legal grounds applies. It can also refer to requests to remove certain links from search results.
Can I make Google delete information about me?
You can submit a request to Google to delist eligible search results associated with your name. Google evaluates the request under applicable data protection rules. Approval is not automatic, and the original webpage may remain online.
Does the right to be forgotten apply worldwide?
No. GDPR protections have a defined territorial scope. The CJEU ruled in 2019 that EU law does not require search engines to apply delisting globally across every version of their services.
Can a newspaper refuse to remove an old article?
Yes, in some circumstances. Freedom of expression and information is an important exception under Article 17(3)(a). A publisher may have a legitimate reason to retain a report, depending on the public interest, accuracy, context and applicable national law.
How long does an organization have to respond to an erasure request?
Under GDPR Article 12(3), the usual deadline is one month from receipt. An organization may extend the period by up to two additional months when necessary because of complexity or the number of requests, but it must notify the individual within the initial month.
Can a company refuse to delete my personal data?
Yes. It may refuse where an applicable exception applies, such as freedom of expression, a legal obligation to retain the information, public interest, certain research or archiving purposes, or the establishment, exercise or defence of legal claims.
Can I remove information that is true but embarrassing?
Possibly, but embarrassment alone does not guarantee deletion. The organization or search engine will assess the relevant legal grounds, the age and nature of the information, the person’s role and the public interest in continued access.
Does deleting an account remove all my personal data?
Not necessarily. A service may retain some information where required by law or where another GDPR exception applies. It should distinguish information that must be deleted from records that can lawfully be retained.
What is the difference between the right to erasure and the right to rectification?
The right to erasure asks for personal data to be deleted in qualifying circumstances. The right to rectification under Article 16 asks an organization to correct inaccurate personal data or complete incomplete information.
Does the right to be forgotten apply outside Europe?
The GDPR can apply to certain organizations outside the EU when they process personal data within its territorial scope. Other countries have their own privacy laws and may provide different deletion or search-removal rights.
Conclusion: A Right to Erasure, Not a Guarantee of Digital Oblivion
The right to be forgotten gives individuals an important way to challenge the continued use and visibility of personal information. Under GDPR Article 17, people can request deletion when information is no longer necessary, consent has been withdrawn without another legal basis, processing is unlawful or another specified ground applies.
But the right has clear limits. Journalism, freedom of expression, public interest, legal obligations and historical records can justify retaining information. Search engine delisting is also geographically limited and does not necessarily remove the original webpage or copies held elsewhere.
Ultimately, the right to be forgotten is best understood as a legal mechanism for balancing privacy with other important rightsânot as a promise that everything published online can be erased. For individuals, it offers a structured way to challenge unnecessary or unlawful processing. For organizations, it creates a responsibility to evaluate requests fairly, document decisions and respect the privacy rights of the people whose data they hold.
Official Sources and Further Reading
- General Data Protection Regulation â Article 17 and related provisions
- CJEU â Google Spain, Case C-131/12
- CJEU â Google v CNIL, Case C-507/17
- CJEU â GC and Others v CNIL, Case C-136/17
- European Data Protection Board
- EDPB â 2025 Coordinated Enforcement Framework report on the right to erasure (published 2026)
- Irish Data Protection Commission â Right to erasure
- European Commission â Dealing with requests from individuals
- Google â Right to Be Forgotten overview
Disclaimer: This article is for general informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The availability of erasure or delisting depends on the applicable law, the type of information, the organization involved and the circumstances of the request. Individuals and organizations should seek qualified legal advice for specific cases.