International data transfers are essential to modern business. Companies rely on cloud platforms, overseas customer support teams, global payment processors, analytics providers and software services that may store or access personal information from different countries. But transferring personal data outside the European Economic Area (EEA) can create significant legal obligations under the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).
The landmark Schrems II judgment changed the way organizations approach these transfers. The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) invalidated the EUâUS Privacy Shield and made clear that Standard Contractual Clauses (SCCs) cannot be used as a formality without examining the laws and practices of the destination country.
Since then, businesses have had to reconsider vendor contracts, international data flows, encryption strategies and privacy risk assessments. The EUâUS Data Privacy Framework (DPF), adopted in 2023, provides another transfer route for eligible US organizations, but it does not eliminate the need for careful compliance.
1. What Was the Schrems II Decision?
Schrems II refers to the judgment delivered by the CJEU on July 16, 2020, in Case C-311/18, Data Protection Commissioner v Facebook Ireland and Maximillian Schrems.
The case arose from concerns about the transfer of European users’ personal data to the United States and the ability of US public authorities to access information held by technology companies. Austrian privacy activist Maximillian Schrems challenged the legal basis used for transfers from Facebook Ireland to its US operations.
The Court reached two particularly important conclusions:
- The EUâUS Privacy Shield was invalid. The Court found that the framework did not provide protection essentially equivalent to that guaranteed under EU law, particularly in relation to certain US surveillance practices and the remedies available to individuals.
- Standard Contractual Clauses remained valid in principle. However, their use depends on whether the data transferred can actually receive an adequate level of protection in the destination country. If the clauses cannot be complied with in practice, additional measures may be required or the transfer must be suspended.
The judgment did not prohibit all transfers of personal data to the United States or other countries outside the EEA. Instead, it reinforced the requirement to assess whether the legal and practical conditions in the destination country undermine the protections provided by the GDPR.
2. Why Schrems II Changed International Data Transfers
Before the judgment, many businesses treated SCCs as a relatively straightforward contractual solution for sending personal data to countries without an EU adequacy decision. Schrems II made clear that organizations must look beyond the wording of the contract.
Companies now need to consider the practical environment in which data is processed, including whether public authorities can access the information and whether the recipient can effectively challenge requests that conflict with the contractual safeguards.
From contract signing to real-world risk assessment
| Before Schrems II | After Schrems II |
|---|---|
| Organizations often focused on signing the appropriate transfer clauses. | Organizations must assess the destination country’s laws and practices as well as the contract. |
| Vendor agreements were sometimes treated as the main compliance step. | Companies must examine actual data access, processing activities and onward transfers. |
| International transfers were often reviewed during contract negotiations only. | Transfer assessments should be revisited when relevant circumstances change. |
| Encryption was frequently considered a general security measure. | Companies must assess whether encryption is effective against the specific risks, including access by the recipient or public authorities. |
Which businesses are affected?
The judgment is relevant to organizations that transfer personal data from the EEA to a country without an applicable adequacy decision. It can affect:
- Companies using cloud hosting providers outside the EEA.
- Online stores using international payment and fraud-prevention services.
- Businesses outsourcing customer support to overseas teams.
- Marketing agencies using analytics and advertising platforms.
- Multinational companies sharing employee data between offices.
- Software providers processing customer information on global infrastructure.
- Organizations using AI services that receive personal information from European users.
3. Legal Mechanisms for Cross-Border Data Transfers
Chapter V of the GDPR establishes several mechanisms for transferring personal data to countries outside the EEA. Companies should identify which mechanism applies to each transfer rather than assuming that one solution covers every vendor or destination.
1. Adequacy decisions â Article 45
The European Commission can recognize that a non-EEA country, territory, sector or international organization provides an adequate level of data protection. When an adequacy decision applies, personal data can generally be transferred within its scope without additional authorization or SCCs.
Examples of jurisdictions with EU adequacy decisions include the United Kingdom, Japan, Switzerland, South Korea and several others. The precise scope and conditions differ by decision, so companies should check the current European Commission list.
2. Standard Contractual Clauses â Article 46
SCCs are pre-approved contractual terms adopted by the European Commission. They provide safeguards for transfers to countries that do not benefit from an applicable adequacy decision.
They are widely used because they can cover different relationships between controllers and processors. However, after Schrems II, organizations must assess whether the clauses can be complied with in the destination country and whether supplementary measures are needed.
3. Binding Corporate Rules â Article 47
Binding Corporate Rules (BCRs) are internal data protection policies approved by a competent supervisory authority. They allow multinational corporate groups to transfer personal data between their entities under a common set of enforceable privacy commitments.
BCRs can be useful for large organizations with frequent transfers between subsidiaries, but they require a substantial approval process and ongoing governance.
4. Specific derogations â Article 49
Article 49 provides limited exceptions for particular circumstances, such as explicit consent after informing the individual of the risks, performance of a contract in certain situations, important reasons of public interest and certain legal claims.
These derogations are not intended to become a routine replacement for adequacy decisions, SCCs or BCRs. Organizations should not rely on consent or contractual necessity as a blanket justification for systematic international transfers.
| Transfer mechanism | When it may be used | Important consideration |
|---|---|---|
| Adequacy decision | The destination country or covered sector has a valid EU adequacy decision. | Check the decision’s scope and whether the recipient is covered. |
| Standard Contractual Clauses | Transfers to recipients in countries without an applicable adequacy decision. | Complete the correct module and assess destination-country risks. |
| Binding Corporate Rules | Transfers within an approved multinational corporate group. | Requires regulatory approval and ongoing compliance. |
| Article 49 derogations | Specific, exceptional situations that meet the relevant legal conditions. | Not a general solution for regular, large-scale transfers. |
4. How Standard Contractual Clauses Work After Schrems II
The European Commission adopted modernized Standard Contractual Clauses on June 4, 2021, through Implementing Decision (EU) 2021/914. They were designed to reflect the GDPR and the requirements established by the Schrems II judgment.
The clauses provide contractual safeguards between the data exporter and importer. They also address data subject rights, security obligations, government access requests and the responsibilities of parties involved in processing chains.
The four SCC modules
| Module | Relationship | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Module 1 | Controller to controller | An EU business shares customer information with an independent overseas business. |
| Module 2 | Controller to processor | An EU retailer transfers customer data to a cloud provider outside the EEA. |
| Module 3 | Processor to processor | An EEA service provider uses an overseas subprocessor to handle customer data. |
| Module 4 | Processor to controller | An EEA processor transfers data back to a non-EEA controller. |
What must companies do when using SCCs?
- Select the module that matches the parties’ actual roles.
- Complete the relevant annexes with accurate information about the transfer.
- Identify the categories of personal data and data subjects involved.
- Describe the purposes, frequency and duration of processing.
- Document technical and organizational security measures.
- Identify relevant subprocessors and onward transfers.
- Assess the laws and practices of the destination country.
- Determine whether supplementary measures are necessary.
The core SCC text cannot be freely rewritten. The parties can select relevant modules and options, complete the annexes and add compatible safeguards, but material changes to the standard clauses may undermine their status as Commission-approved SCCs.
5. What Is a Transfer Impact Assessment?
A Transfer Impact Assessment (TIA) is an evaluation of whether personal data transferred to a third country can receive the level of protection required by EU law. It is particularly important when an organization relies on SCCs or another Article 46 transfer mechanism.
The European Commission’s 2021 SCCs address this assessment in Clause 14. The parties must consider whether the laws and practices of the destination country could prevent the data importer from complying with the contractual safeguards.
What should a TIA examine?
Identify whether the transfer includes ordinary contact information, financial records, health information, employee data, location records or other sensitive categories. Consider whether the data is identifiable and how much information is being transferred.
Explain why the data needs to leave the EEA. A transfer for basic technical hosting may involve different risks from a transfer for behavioral profiling, advertising or intelligence-related services.
Identify the data importer, its ownership, business activities, service model and any relevant relationships with public authorities. Consider whether it acts as a controller, processor or subprocessor.
Evaluate legal powers that may permit public authorities to access the data, applicable limitations and safeguards, and the availability of effective remedies for individuals.
Examine whether the recipient can access data in intelligible form, whether it controls encryption keys and whether the data is exposed through support tools, administrative access or other technical arrangements.
Determine whether technical, contractual or organizational measures can address identified risks. If the safeguards cannot provide the required level of protection, the transfer should not proceed on that basis.
Is a TIA required for every international transfer?
The assessment depends on the transfer mechanism. A valid adequacy decision under Article 45 generally provides the required basis for transfers within its scope, so a Schrems II-style assessment under Clause 14 of the SCCs is not ordinarily required for that same transfer.
When relying on SCCs, BCRs or other Article 46 safeguards, organizations should assess the circumstances of the transfer and the relevant destination-country legal environment. The assessment should be documented and revisited when relevant facts change.
6. Supplementary Measures Companies Should Consider
If the transfer assessment identifies risks that the standard contractual safeguards cannot address by themselves, companies may need supplementary measures. The European Data Protection Board (EDPB) identifies technical, contractual and organizational measures that can help protect transferred information.
Technical measures
- Strong encryption: Encrypt personal data during transmission and storage using robust, current cryptographic methods.
- Control encryption keys: Where appropriate, keep keys under the control of the EEA exporter or another trusted entity so the importer cannot independently access intelligible data.
- Pseudonymization: Replace direct identifiers with pseudonyms before transfer, while keeping additional identifying information separately protected.
- Data minimization: Transfer only the information necessary for the intended service.
- Access restrictions: Limit access to authorized personnel and apply strong authentication and monitoring.
Encryption is not a universal solution. If the overseas provider needs to process personal data in clear text, or has access to the encryption keys, encryption at rest may not protect against every relevant access risk. The measure must be evaluated against the actual processing scenario.
Contractual measures
- Require the importer to notify the exporter about government access requests where legally permitted.
- Require the importer to assess the legality of requests and challenge unlawful or disproportionate demands where appropriate.
- Provide for transparency reporting and cooperation between the parties.
- Require appropriate security controls and restrictions on onward transfers.
- Establish audit, suspension and termination rights where applicable.
Organizational measures
- Restrict the number of employees who can access transferred data.
- Train staff on government access requests and privacy incidents.
- Maintain records of data access and transfer decisions.
- Separate identifying information from datasets used for analysis.
- Establish procedures for reviewing vendors and subprocessors.
7. The EUâUS Data Privacy Framework: What Changed?
After the invalidation of the Privacy Shield, the European Union and United States negotiated a new framework intended to address the concerns identified in Schrems II.
On July 10, 2023, the European Commission adopted an adequacy decision for the EUâUS Data Privacy Framework. This allows personal data to flow from the EU to US organizations that participate in the framework and are covered by its certification.
How does the framework work?
The DPF is based on commitments made by participating US organizations and changes to the US legal framework governing certain national security access to personal data. The US measures include safeguards intended to ensure that signals intelligence activities are necessary and proportionate, together with a redress mechanism for qualifying complaints from individuals in Europe.
Unlike the former Privacy Shield, the DPF is supported by the US Executive Order of October 7, 2022, and related regulations. The Commission’s adequacy decision concluded that the framework provided an adequate level of protection for transfers covered by the decision.
Can companies transfer data to any US company under the DPF?
No. The adequacy decision applies to US organizations that have self-certified and are listed as active participants in the Data Privacy Framework, within the scope of their certification.
Before relying on the framework, an EU exporter should:
- Search the official Data Privacy Framework participant list.
- Confirm that the recipient’s certification is active.
- Check that the certification covers the relevant entity and types of information.
- Review the recipient’s privacy commitments and the intended processing.
- Document the basis for relying on the adequacy decision.
If the US recipient is not covered by the DPF, the exporter may need another valid transfer mechanism, such as SCCs, together with the relevant assessment and safeguards.
Is the Data Privacy Framework still valid in 2026?
As of November 22, 2026, the EUâUS Data Privacy Framework adequacy decision remains in force. On September 3, 2025, the EU General Court dismissed an action seeking to annul the decision in Case T-553/23, Latombe v Commission. The judgment upheld the Commission’s assessment as of the date the decision was adopted.
However, the legal landscape continues to develop. The case has been taken to the Court of Justice on appeal, and further challenges have been discussed. The existence of litigation does not itself suspend the adequacy decision. Businesses should monitor official updates and verify the framework’s status before relying on it.
DPF versus SCCs: What is the difference?
| Feature | EUâUS Data Privacy Framework | Standard Contractual Clauses |
|---|---|---|
| Legal basis | EU adequacy decision under Article 45 | Appropriate safeguards under Article 46 |
| Who can use it? | US organizations covered by an active DPF certification | Eligible exporters and importers using the relevant SCC module |
| Transfer assessment | Generally no SCC-style TIA is required for a transfer covered by the adequacy decision | Destination-country assessment is required in the Schrems II context |
| Contract requirements | Must verify the recipient’s certification and applicable commitments | Must execute and complete the appropriate clauses and annexes |
| Geographic scope | Covered US organizations | Can support transfers to recipients in many third countries |
8. Practical Compliance Steps for Businesses
Companies should treat international transfers as an ongoing governance responsibility rather than a one-time legal exercise. The following process can help organizations build a manageable compliance program.
Step 1: Map all international data flows
Identify every service, vendor and internal system that may send or allow access to personal data outside the EEA. Include cloud hosting, email platforms, CRM systems, analytics tools, advertising services, payment processors and remote support teams.
Step 2: Identify the parties and their roles
Determine which entity acts as controller, processor or subprocessor. A vendor’s corporate headquarters may be in one country while its infrastructure, support personnel and subprocessors are located elsewhere.
Step 3: Confirm the transfer mechanism
Check whether an adequacy decision applies. If not, assess whether SCCs, BCRs or another valid Article 46 mechanism is available. Use Article 49 derogations only when their specific conditions are met.
Step 4: Review vendor documentation
Request the vendor’s data processing agreement, SCCs where relevant, subprocessor list, security documentation, privacy information and details of international data access. Avoid relying only on marketing statements about compliance.
Step 5: Conduct and document the TIA
When required, examine the destination country’s laws and practices, the data categories, the recipient’s role, potential public authority access and the effectiveness of available safeguards.
Step 6: Implement supplementary protections
Use appropriate encryption, pseudonymization, access restrictions, contractual commitments and organizational controls. The choice should address the specific risks identified in the assessment.
Step 7: Update privacy notices and records
Make sure privacy information accurately explains international transfers, recipients or recipient categories, relevant safeguards and how individuals can obtain information about those safeguards.
Step 8: Monitor changes
Review transfers when a vendor changes its infrastructure, adds a subprocessor, changes ownership, expands its services or becomes subject to new legal requirements. Revisit assessments when the legal or practical circumstances materially change.
Step 9: Prepare an exit strategy
Contracts should allow the business to suspend or terminate a transfer if the importer can no longer comply with the relevant safeguards. Consider how data will be returned, deleted or migrated to another provider.
Step 10: Assign responsibility
Make sure legal, privacy, procurement, IT security and business teams understand their roles. A transfer register and clear approval process can help prevent unreviewed international data flows.
9. Common Mistakes Companies Should Avoid
SCCs are a transfer tool, not a substitute for assessing destination-country laws and the actual ability of the importer to comply.
The framework applies to eligible participating organizations. Companies must verify the recipient’s active certification and scope.
Data can be accessed from another country even when the main server is physically located in Europe. Vendor support arrangements and administrative access should be reviewed.
Article 49 consent derogations have specific requirements and are not designed to support routine, repeated transfers at scale.
A vendor may rely on other companies for hosting, analytics, security or customer support. Those additional parties can create further transfer risks.
A TIA prepared several years ago may no longer reflect current laws, vendor practices, data flows or technical safeguards.
10. Cross-Border Data Transfer Compliance Checklist
Use this interactive checklist to review the essential elements of an international transfer program.
11. What Does Schrems II Mean for Cloud Computing and AI?
Cloud computing and artificial intelligence make international data transfers more complex because information can move between multiple providers, regions and processing environments.
Cloud services
A company may select an EU data center but still need to examine whether personnel or affiliated entities outside the EEA can access the data. It should review administrative access, technical support, backup locations, subprocessors and the provider’s legal commitments.
AI platforms and model providers
When employees submit personal data to an AI tool, the information may be processed by the provider or its subprocessors in another country. Businesses should determine whether the tool uses submitted information for model improvement, where processing occurs, who can access prompts and outputs, and whether the provider retains the data.
Organizations should also consider whether personal data can be removed, anonymized or pseudonymized before it is sent to an external AI service. If the provider receives identifiable information, the relevant GDPR and international transfer requirements may apply.
Global customer support
Giving overseas support agents access to customer accounts can create international transfer issues even if the database remains in the EEA. Businesses should assess the access arrangement, limit permissions and determine which transfer mechanism and safeguards are appropriate.
12. Frequently Asked Questions
What is Schrems II in simple terms?
Schrems II is a 2020 CJEU judgment that invalidated the EUâUS Privacy Shield and clarified that international transfers using SCCs must provide protection essentially equivalent to EU standards. Companies may need to assess destination-country laws and implement additional safeguards.
Did Schrems II ban transfers of data to the United States?
No. It invalidated the Privacy Shield, not all transfers to the United States. Transfers may be possible through an applicable adequacy decision, such as the EUâUS Data Privacy Framework for covered organizations, or another valid GDPR transfer mechanism.
Are Standard Contractual Clauses still valid after Schrems II?
Yes. SCCs remain a recognized GDPR transfer mechanism. However, companies must assess whether the clauses can be complied with in the destination country and whether supplementary measures are needed.
What is a Transfer Impact Assessment?
A Transfer Impact Assessment evaluates whether personal data transferred to a third country can receive the protection required under EU law. It examines the specific transfer, the recipient, destination-country laws and practices, and the effectiveness of safeguards.
Does every international transfer require a TIA?
Not every transfer requires the same assessment. Transfers covered by an applicable adequacy decision generally do not require an SCC-style transfer impact assessment. Transfers relying on SCCs and other Article 46 safeguards require an assessment appropriate to the circumstances and applicable guidance.
What is the difference between SCCs and the Data Privacy Framework?
SCCs are contractual safeguards that can support transfers to recipients in many third countries. The EUâUS Data Privacy Framework is an adequacy mechanism for transfers to eligible US organizations that are covered by an active certification.
Can a company use US cloud services and remain GDPR compliant?
Yes, provided the company identifies the relevant data flows, uses a valid transfer mechanism where required, evaluates the provider’s access and processing arrangements, and applies appropriate safeguards.
What happens if supplementary measures are insufficient?
If the required level of protection cannot be achieved, the transfer cannot proceed on the basis of the chosen Article 46 mechanism. An existing transfer may need to be suspended or ended.
Does Schrems II apply to companies outside the EU?
The judgment concerns the interpretation of EU data protection law. A company outside the EU may still have obligations when it processes personal data within the GDPR’s territorial scope or receives data from an EU organization under a GDPR transfer mechanism.
Is the EUâUS Data Privacy Framework still in force in 2026?
As of November 22, 2026, the European Commission’s adequacy decision remains in force. A 2025 challenge was dismissed by the EU General Court, but litigation has continued on appeal. Businesses should monitor official developments and verify that a US recipient remains covered by the framework.
Conclusion: International Data Transfers Require More Than a Contract
The Schrems II judgment fundamentally changed how companies must approach cross-border data transfers. Organizations can no longer assume that signing Standard Contractual Clauses automatically resolves every privacy risk. They need to understand where information travels, who can access it, what legal protections apply and whether additional safeguards are effective.
The EUâUS Data Privacy Framework provides a route for transfers to covered US organizations, while SCCs and Binding Corporate Rules remain important tools for other international arrangements. However, every mechanism has conditions and limitations that businesses must understand.
For companies using global cloud services, marketing platforms, AI tools or outsourced support, the most reliable starting point is a complete data-flow inventory, a documented transfer strategy and regular reviews of vendors and safeguards. International business can continue, but personal data must remain protected wherever it goes.
Official Sources and Further Reading
- CJEU â Case C-311/18, Schrems II
- European Commission â International dimension of data protection
- European Commission â Standard Contractual Clauses FAQs
- EDPB â Recommendations 01/2020 on supplementary measures
- EDPB â Adequacy decisions and EUâUS DPF guidance
- EDPB â Standard Contractual Clauses
- European Commission â EUâUS Data Privacy Framework
- CJEU â Case T-553/23, Latombe v Commission, September 2025
- Official Data Privacy Framework participant list
Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice. International transfer requirements depend on the parties, data categories, processing activities, destination country and applicable legal instruments. Companies should obtain qualified legal advice before implementing or changing cross-border data transfer arrangements.